Meditation News

Is Meditation Selfish?

Is Meditation Selfish

Flash mob meditations around the world is a rapidly growing movement. It's a group meditation.

Is meditation selfish?

That is a question that keeps coming up.

Thousands of years ago there was a division among Buddhists.  The Mahayana school suggested rather strongly that the old-school Theraveda group had become too sel-centered in their practices.  I cannot speak to the rightness or wrongness of this, but I have spent a great deal of time with Theraveda people, and they are uniformly open-hearted, generous and service oriented,

Here’s parts of the article that got me thinking about meditation and selfishness –

Is Meditation Selfish?

Mark Vernon questions the merits of Buddhism as interpreted by the West:

[I]n meditation, Buddhism offers a therapy that tackles the hyper-individualism of today by stressing the instability and dissolution of the self. Only, it seems to me that is not true. Whilst it may be very hard to say what an ‘I’ is – and it is surely multiple and porous – it is foolish to rush to concluding there’s no ‘I’ at all. It is less reactionary, surely, to rest with the notion that we are something of a mystery to ourselves – a mystery deepened in meditative analysis, not dissolved in it.

As a Jew who joined the Buddhist/meditation club in college for the cute boy who chaired it and the free retreat to Cape Cod, I’m not qualified to speak to the religious aspect. But Josh Rothman, summarizing philosopher Owen Flanagan’s book The Bodhisattva’s Brain: Buddhism Naturalized, does a good job refuting Vernon:

In the Buddhist world, materialism and determinism can be morally informative. First, they suggest that we aren’t as important or permanent as we think we are — that, in a fundamental sense, our selves or souls don’t really exist in any lasting way (a conclusion, incidentally, shared by Western philosophers like John Locke and Derek Parfit). This, in turn, suggests that satisfying our own personal needs and wants shouldn’t be our number-one priority; instead, we should focus on projects that benefit everyone, and work to become more kind and generous to our fellow human beings.

Some behaviors that appear selfish can make us better in and to the world.

What’s your opinion?

 Is meditation selfish?

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To Top